As I've said, I don't own one of these. Most everything I comment on, is general knowledge from many years of mixed experience.
But about your O-ring. If it's truly a rubber O-ring, then I'd keep reusing it, after checking it for damage. And putting a little liquid silicone on it, to make it last a bit longer.
I'd most definitely match it up with a new one, at the next oil change, to be used as a spare when the original gives up. Replace it every couple of years, as it coincides with normal oil changes. Or sooner, obviously, if there's any sign of anything other than perfect.